Rev. Carmelo Santos has been asking the deeper questions that neuroscience is not likely to explore on its own, but in many ways what he's found has the power to unite and reignite the church as a whole.

    Santos serves as the Director for Theological Diversity and Ecumenical and Inter-Religious Engagement at the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA). Much of his work during his career has focused on neuroscience and exploring the field of neurotheology.

    He grew up in Puerto Rico by the beach across the bay from San Juan in a small town called Catano. He received his B.S. in chemistry from the University of Puerto Rico, where he specialized in organometallic synthesis. For his seminary and Ph.D. work he chose the Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago because they had the Zygon Center for Religion and Science as well as an emphasis on Hispanic ministries.

    His academic work, including lectures and teaching courses on "God & the Brain," has centered on neuroscience, liberation and postcolonial theologies with an emphasis on pneumatology (the study of the Holy Spirit) and theological anthropology.

    His latest book, A Liberation Theology of the Brain: Neuroscience, Theology, and Decolonizing Emotions, was recently published by Fortress Press. He details a theological framework, informed by science, that leaves room for an appreciation of the Spirit of God at work ‘in, with, and under" neurons, bodies and communities.

    Covalence caught up with Santos just after the book launch with some questions about how he handles the complexity of the theology, science and the human experience to inform the shared work of the church. We also discussed the lasting impact of post-colonialism and what it means for congregations today.

    This Q&A will be in two installments. The first this month looks broadly at what it means to take a neuroscientific approach to theology, and the second installment will plan to dive more into the idea of decolonization and how it fits into the mental health and life of the church.

    Q: Liberation theology offers up a very timely lens by which to explore neuroscience and theology or neurotheology. What drew you to incorporating social justice as well as decolonization themes with what is happening at a synaptic level?

    Santos: I love Chemistry. I love theology. I love God. I love people. And I love creation. Not necessarily in that order. I love Chemistry (and science in general) because it gives me a lens through which I can delight in observing God's creative, healing, redemptive, and playful work unfolding in creation. It allows me to see the brain and the nervous system as a dynamic interface where Spirit and Matter dance, like the water and the waves dance in the ocean when caressed by the wind, by the sun, and by the distant yet near gravitational touch of the moon. Not in a dualistic way but in a kind of (metaphoric) perichoretic quantum entanglement that distinguishes but does not separate, and that unites but does not confuse those who are dancing. I learned from the incarnational theology of Luther, from the embodied theology of Feminists, Womanists, and Mujeristas, and from the relational worldview of process theology that God is at work not vis-à-vis our materiality but precisely deep within it.

    While studying neuroscience in dialogue with theology (at LSTC's Advance Seminar in Religion and Science, many years ago), I became fascinated by the idea that the Spirit leaves tangible tracks not only in our souls or even in our minds but actually in our brains and nervous system. I referred to those in my dissertation as "symptoms of God's Spirit," using the word symptom as a kind of physiological equivalent to Paul Tillich's understanding of symbol (that which points to a reality beyond itself that it is, therefore, not itself but in which it participates). That interpretive device allowed me to circumvent dead-end debates on whether the correlation between neural activity and religious experience is proof that God is no longer necessary as an explanation (because we now know that it is all nothing but brain activity) or whether this is finally empirical proof of God's existence (notwithstanding the contradiction inherent to the need for such a proof). Phillip Melanchthon famously said that to know Christ is to know his benefits, in a sense, thinking of the neural correlates of religious experience as potential "symptoms of God's Spirit" allowed me to focus on the dimension of those benefits instantiated deep within our embodied being.

    From Liberation theologies I learned that those benefits of Christ (in the power of the Spirit) are vaster than the impression given by our traditions' narrow focus on forgiveness of sins. Despite shallow and unfair interpretations of liberation theology, its emphasis is not just on economic and political liberation à la Marx. Liberation theology approaches the message of the Scriptures from below, from the perspective of those who have the boots of the powerful on their necks, from those exploited for the sake of the increase of profit of others, from the perspective of those excluded, pushed to the margins, or dehumanized because the particular expression of their embodiment viewed (judged) through invented hierarchies of race, ethnicity, sexual identities, gender expression, physical or mental diversities and disabilities, age, immigration status, etc. When viewed through those lenses the benefits of Christ (in the power of the Spirit) include things like healing, justice (including economic justice, climate justice, gender justice, racial justice, etc.), social transformation, and, yes, forgiveness, which is the heart of the gospel.

    The liberation that we have in Christ brings about a change in the way we experience the world and the way we feel and perceive each other. This is an "already/not yet" type of phenomenon. But it is instantiated by changes in our brain and nervous system (and, as I argue in the book, in our guts and microbiota). Neuroscience allows us to probe how we are impacted by the word of God at a very embodied level. Luther said that the influence of the word of God in the believer is comparable to the way that iron in the hearth of the iron smith is transformed into the heat and glow of fire. Neuroscience allows us to investigate how our brain, our cognitive devices, our nervous system, our immune systems, etc., are actually shaped by different expressions of the word of God, in worship, in private contemplation, in ritual, in religious practices, etc. And neuroscience, in turn, can receive from theology an invitation to a reverent sense of awe before the vastness of the phenomena it studies and to humbly recognize the limits of its own gaze and the need for other ways of knowing.

    Q: What are the emotions at play? Why are they important?

    Santos: All emotions are important. All emotions can become opportunities for what theologian Mayra Rivera calls the touch of transcendence. That doesn't mean that transcendence, or the experience of God, can be reduced to an emotion or even to a set of emotions. All emotions can play a role in God's work of bringing healing and wholeness to our lives, to our communities, and to the world. What is an emotion? I think neuroscientists are still working out a precise definition and theory that they can all agree on. That is not a bad thing, that is how science is supposed to work, but it makes it very challenging for those of us trying to understand the science from the outside.

    In any case, what I understand to be the case is that emotions are first of all physiological responses to external stimuli. Emotions are the way our bodies respond to (or prepare to respond) to what is perceiving in the world they inhabit. As the body generates energy for action (e.g., fight?, flight?, feed?, copulate?)  vis-à-vis what is perceiving, it also produces sensations within the body (interoception) that the brain then interprets as specific emotions. Those emotions orient action and decision making. What I find theologically interesting is that those emotions also shape perception. Emotions themselves, in turn, are not preset into universal categories as we used to think to be the case but instead they are profoundly shaped by language. I am following here the research of Lisa Feldman Barrett, How Emotions Are Made: The Secret Life of the Brain (Boston: Mariner Books, 2017). Language shapes emotion and emotion shapes perception, orients action and informs decision making.

    That has tremendous implications for our understanding of how we perceive, experience and treat each other in terms of race, ethnicity, gender, class, sexual orientation, political affiliation, and whatever other categories we invent as a society to classify each other. This is especially true in a context, in the Americas, including the United States of America, layered with five hundred years of coloniality, enslavement (of different kinds), racism, patriarchy, heteronormativity, and anthropocentrism. Through the alchemy of language and emotion certain peculiar ways of perceiving reality acquire what I call in the book ontological weight so that we forget such categories are not rooted in the nature of things themselves, nor do they come from God, but rather are of human fabrication. That doesn't mean that there is no diversity across humanity and creation but the hierarchical ordering of that diversity (e.g., some humans are more human than others), and the biases associated with them are a fabrication of the human mind under the conditions of sin.

    Because the way we perceive and experience reality is shaped by emotion and language, theology has an important role to play in what we could call "affective world-making." Theology, as the interpretation and articulation of the word of God for new contexts and circumstances produces words that have the power to penetrate deep within peoples embodied selves (all the way from the brain to the viscera) and transforms what I refer to in the book as their generative affective grammars. This is particularly true when the theology is embodied in ritual (e.g., worship, contemplation, prayer), in quotidian practices, and in community. The world we inhabit perceptually and affectively is created by the Word.

    Q: Where does spirituality fit in?

    Santos: It is all spirituality. The Word is a verb, an event, not just a noun. It is Dabar, in Hebrew, and also Hocma (Wisdom) a word that is active, creative, and therefore, to "know" the word is to abide in the word, or to let the word abide in us, moving us and transforming us in the process. Spirituality is how our relationship with the Word (the living word of God which is Christ, made available to us by the Holy Spirit through the Scriptures) unfolds.

    In his short story, "Axolotl," Argentinian writer Julio Cortazar, tells the tale of a man who would come to the zoo every day to contemplate the strange-looking salamander known as axolotl. His attention becomes so absorbed by the creature that in a plot twist typical of Latin American magical realism, the observer becomes the observed. He could now see himself from the perspective of the salamander. He had become the axolotl while still being himself and while the axolotl was still itself. We become what we contemplate. Neuroscientists would say that our brains mirror what we perceive. Therefore, we must be mindful of what we choose to contemplate, what we choose to give our attention to. When we contemplate the word, we become transformed by the word. (Remember Luther's image of iron being transformed by fire). Thus, we are transformed by the Word in the power of the Holy Spirit via spirituality in ways that have biological effects on our brain, nervous system, immunological system, and even at the level of epigenetics.

    But our spirituality should be Trinitarian. I don't mean only that it should be focused on the Triune God, although that is certainly important for those of us in the Christian tradition. What I mean is that spirituality is not only between me and God. A third is needed. It is in my relationships with my neighbors and my fellow creatures that I live out my faith, and that God often comes to my encounter. That is one of the most important contributions of the Reformation to the church, the idea that we do not have to isolate ourselves from the world and from our neighbors and enter the monastic cloister in order to live out our relationship with Christ (our spirituality) and our vocation. It is precisely in the context of our daily lives and of our daily vocations, in our interactions with our neighbors, that our spirituality takes flesh. It is in our interactions with others that we rehearse the life of the "world to come" (the otherwise) promised by God. The new heavens and the new earth, where all tears are wiped and the leaves of the tree are for the healing of the nations. 

    Susan Barreto

    Susan is an author with a long-time interest in religion and science. She currently edits Covalence, the Lutheran Alliance for Faith, Science and Technology’s online magazine. She has written articles in The Lutheran and the Zygon Center for Religion and Science newsletter. Susan is a board member for the Center for Advanced Study of Religion and Science, the supporting organization for the Zygon Center and the Zygon Journal. She also co-wrote Our Bodies Are Selves with Dr. Philip Hefner and Dr. Ann Pederson.

    Subscribe To Our Newsletter

    Subscribe To Our Newsletter

    Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team!

    You have Successfully Subscribed!