This month's issue highlights multiple touchpoints of theological engagement between the human mind, science and faith. Our interview with theologian Carmelo Santos in fact provides a real-world example of how our brain engages with a shared history as well as with the Holy Spirit.
Following our interview, I came across an Associated Press story that offered an interesting round-up of quotes from leaders in the realm of artificial intelligence pointing out that Silicon Valley is sounding religious. I admit it was hard to be surprised as this kind of development has been explored by theologians for more than a decade.
There was also a very timely tinge of apocalypse and transhumanism, which are previous topics explored, in greater detail than I can do justice to here, at a previous IRAS Star Island Conferences entitled "AI and Apocalypse" held in 2019.
One of the big quotes in the story was from Geoffrey Hinton, Nobel Prize Winner and the so-called ‘Godfather of AI' for his role in developing Google's AI and for quitting the project over his concerns over AI's looming transformational impact on humanity and the planet. Hinton said, "I think religion will be in trouble if we create other beings. Once we start creating beings that can think for themselves and do things for themselves, maybe even have bodies if they're robots, we may start realizing we're less special than we thought. And the idea that we're very special and we were made in the image of God, that idea may go out the window."
It's a controversial idea especially as large language models (LLMs) learn more and more about us and our world, directly in very innocuous ways across the world wide web. Through ChatGPT, AI has learned how to draft new prayers and has even taken on the role of Jesus in a Swiss church last year.
According to author and computer scientist Ray Kurzweil, "By 2045, which is only 20 years from now, we'll be a million times more powerful. And we'll be able to have expertise in every field." Some would view that idea as a promise and others maybe a threat, especially if they care about destructive use of energy sources that are dwindling around the world.
One scholar, Max Tegmark, even compared the four big AI company CEOs to modern-day prophets, recently describing them as having different gospels.
In my day job as a financial journalist, I've heard many staggering claims whether it was investment in ‘renewable' resources explicitly for data centers supporting A.I. or by marketing teams finding their CEO's voice and creating material based off of the creation of A.I. personas.
But as Hinton suggests, what if there are A.I. personas that are embodied? It may surprise some computer scientists that theologians have been exploring this topic for years. Now though as financial markets, governments and other institutions are looking at A.I.'s potential, it seems the public is now only discovering.
At the same time, AI vendors seem comfortable seeing their product in the role of savior ,whether it is for a late-night research project or discovering new therapeutic drugs. At the same time, it arguably may be viewed as a pretender as it targets consumers online search activity and purchasing power driven through marketing campaigns.
Still, much has been made about A.I.'s ability to "hallucinate" could be dangerous whether it is in reference to a corporate balance sheets or biblical text. Like any one of us, it may make mistakes as it seems sometimes to be just as human as its creator — at least not yet.
One of the most interesting quotes the Associated Press shared came from Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg talking about his own venture into AI. On a podcast he said, "When people in the tech industry talk about building this one true AI, it's almost as if they think they're creating God or something."
As for the theologians watching AI's rise has quickly changed from recognizing the technologies frailty in recreating the human mind to a more critical analysis of the optimism prevalent such as that encouraged by Kurzweil's prediction above.
Lutheran theologian Ted Peters, wrote last year, "Kurzweil fails to see that AI, like any other technology, is morally ambiguous. It can be used for good or evil. There is no built-in telos or providential hand guiding the law of accelerating concerns."
Additionally, Anne Foerst, an AI ethicist as well as a theologian, has explored this topic for more than 25 years. Her most recent take on developments was one of great concern especially as the U.S. entered a Presidential campaign in 2024.
Foerst emphasized that LLMs are not embodied and they are not self-reflective. They cannot have an ego and will not be able to achieve human consciousness, she added. From an ethics standpoint, the discussion is one of bias in the data the LLMs are being trained with.
She has encouraged those in the church to come out and speak of the dangers of AI. One of the deeper ethical questions is that we can all become too dependent on AI. And that is what investors and entrepreneurs are banking on to happen quickly as part of a growth engine in a new U.S. economy driven by the new technology in areas such as weapons manufacturing and healthcare.
The certainty of AI's continued growth happening is nearly the stuff of a Silicon Valley gospel message in its own right. As data centers pop-up rapidly across the U.S. to meet the demand, it is well worth considering along with the theologians what AI procurement will do to our humanity as well as the planet in the next few years.
Susan is an author with a long-time interest in religion and science. She currently edits Covalence, the Lutheran Alliance for Faith, Science and Technology’s online magazine. She has written articles in The Lutheran and the Zygon Center for Religion and Science newsletter. Susan is a board member for the Center for Advanced Study of Religion and Science, the supporting organization for the Zygon Center and the Zygon Journal. She also co-wrote Our Bodies Are Selves with Dr. Philip Hefner and Dr. Ann Pederson.

